EDIT *this is merely information for your review, in order to assist you in making an informed decision, feel free to come to your own conclusions whether to candle or not to candle your very own ears...you may proceed...
Here is an excerpt of the article I read to the candling crowd on Sat. from webmd, or read the article yourself.
Ear candling is an ancient practice that supposedly removes wax from the ears, thereby improving physical and spiritual well-being. Practitioners use a tapered tube, about a foot long, made out of a rolled-up sheet of cotton that has been coated with beeswax, and sometimes infused with honey or herbs.
They insert the narrow end of the tube, or ear cone, into the patient's ear, and set the other end on fire. The flame supposedly creates a vacuum that sucks ear wax into the tube. After 15 minutes or so, the practitioner douses the flame and pushes a stick through the tube, pushing out ash and melted wax that has been darkened by the smoke so it resembles ear wax.
But it is not ear wax, as several researchers have demonstrated.
For example, clinical psychologist Philip Kaushall, along with Justin Neville Kaushall, performed ear candling the traditional way, and then burned other ear candles that were not inserted in the ear. The residue was always the same.
"Hence the wax that is pushed out from an ear cone is not from the ear, as purported, but rather is a product of the candle itself," they concluded in an article published in Skeptical Inquirer. Ear candles don't produce a vacuum either, so they could not possibly suck wax from the ear.
"Since wax is sticky, the negative pressure needed to pull wax from the canal would have to be so powerful that it would rupture the eardrum," says Lisa M.L. Dryer, MD, writing for quackwatch.org, a web site devoted to combating health-related frauds, myths, fads, and fallacies.
Ear Candling Risks
Ear candling is not just ineffective; it can be dangerous if the burning wax drips into the ear canal.
"I just saw my third case of ear candling fallout this past week in a 33-year-old woman who burned both eardrums and was in chronic pain for days," Richard Carmen, AuD, an audiologist in Sedona, Ariz., tells WebMD. "Damage can be permanent or require reconstructive surgery. What is perceived by consumers as earwax coming out of the cone is actually melting wax from the candle. If consumers are hurt by this product, I encourage them to contact their attorney general."
I really wasn't trying to be a jerk, just trying to look out for the people I care about...when somebody says hey let's light these tubes on fire and stick them in our ears...I'm always gonna look for the "rest of the story." I think that people call that being a cynic, I just like to know what I'm getting in to.
And...for the record Dana, I was just going to feed um some tacos I had NO IDEA!
Monday, February 4, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
My engineering mind shifted into "skeptical" mode immediately. Basically WebMD confirmed what my initial thoughts were:
1. Since the paper is coated with wax, the burned wax is just wax from the paper, not from your ear.
2. If there was any suction or vacuum at all, you would be able to feel it in your eardrum. If you don't feel anything, there is no suction. If there is a suction, it is probably not good for your ear drum.
3. Any cleaning that is accomplished is probably a result of just stuffing the paper in your ear. This can be accomplished with a Q-tip without the fire hazard.
Sorry to be wet blanket.
Hey Brent,
I actually recommended "lets burn one by itself and see what it looks like inside...before taking to the internet" but no one wanted to be a Mythbuster at the couch that night.
Thanks for joining me as a fellow blanket. :)
OK, I just watched the video and about died laughing(and therefore coughing) right here in the office! Good thing everyone is at lunch! I am sorry I missed that one!
I would be completely and totally terrified to do anything like that.
As a person who has taken innumerable classes dealing with the auditory processes, I would never, ever put any flaming device near my ear. The only way to clean your ears in a safe and effective way is to visit your audiologist.
Gosh, my professor would be so proud...
Ya, that wasn't the first time I'd run across Ear Candling, I pretty much go into skeptic mode for anything from Natures Pharm.
Eesh. Glad I left when I did.
Post a Comment